by Traverse Legal, reviewed by Enrico Schaefer - July 26, 2012 - f. Trademark Availability & Monitoring
brand monitoring is a phenomena which really kind of has grown up with the Internet. In the old brick and mortar world, you might worry about someone else using your trademark, but your ability to actually see that someone else was using your trademark or brand was very limited. So you might see an advertisement in the paper if you were lucky, that showed that someone else was using something that was either identical or similar enough to your trademark that it might cause consumer confusion. In the Internet space, now 99% of everything that happens commercially is also reflected on the worldwide web, it's reflected online, so it's very easy to see when other people, third parties, use a brand or mark that is too similar to your preexisting trademark.
Announcer: Welcome to Trademark Law Radio, a top web resource on issues of trademark infringement, trademark licensing, trademark protection and trademark registration.
Matt: Hello and welcome back to Trademark Law Radio. I'm Matt Plessner and today we're going to be covering trademarks and brands online. We're joined once again by Enrico Schaefer from the Traverse Legal Office in Traverse City, Michigan. Enrico, how are you?
Enrico: I'm doing pretty well, Matt. How are you doing?
Matt: Doing very well. Thanks for asking. Now can you start off, please, by telling us exactly what brand monitoring is and how do you go about doing it?
Enrico: Well, brand monitoring is a phenomena which really kind of has grown up with the Internet. In the old brick and mortar world, you might worry about someone else using your trademark, but your ability to actually see that someone else was using your trademark or brand was very limited. So you might see an advertisement in the paper if you were lucky, that showed that someone else was using something that was either identical or similar enough to your trademark that it might cause consumer confusion. In the Internet space, now 99% of everything that happens commercially is also reflected on the worldwide web, it's reflected online, so it's very easy to see when other people, third parties, use a brand or mark that is too similar to your preexisting trademark.
So brand monitoring is the art of trying to gather all of the other third party uses of your trademark into a software system and then using that to identify problems that might occur that you need to follow up on, people infringing your trademark.
Matt: And what are some of the main consequences if one fails to do this?
Enrico: Well, there are several concepts under trademark law that attorneys are constantly worried about for their clients. A trademark attorney will tell you that if you do not protect your trademark, you could potentially lose your trademark rights, even if it's a registered trademark. The most severe consequence for a failure to engage in some sort of brand and trademark monitoring is that if other people start using your mark and you don't do anything about it, you could be subject to the concept of waiver or latches, which would preclude you from actually using your mark to protect your brand down the line.
Matt: Now, what kind of problems, specifically, should you monitor for first?
Enrico: Well, there are really several categories of monitoring, and there's software that good trademark and Internet law attorneys will have available to them on behalf of their clients in order to do this kind of monitoring. The lowest end, Matt, is you could set up a Google alert and get flooded with instances of a particular use. That typically is going to be the poor man's trademark monitoring. There are much more sophisticated pieces of software, and those software components break down into three general categories. Number one is domain names. So it will tell you not only all the other new content that gets posted that a Googler would do, but all uses across the Internet of not only your trademark as a domain name, but anything that is similar to your trademark as a domain name. So it will tell you all the other potential infringing domain names that arguably might infringe your trademark that are out there. So the first category is domain name monitoring for your trademark.
The second category is key word advertising. So are people either using your trademark to trigger ads in either Google Ad Words or Yahoo Overture? Or are they using your trademark as part of their ad text? So really what we call is a key word advertising infringement is another category that you need to monitor for. I'll just kind of add as a side note, Matt, as a trademark and cybersquatting law attorney, the thing that seems to make clients the most angry is when their competitor is actually using your client's trademark as a key work trigger so that when a consumer is looking for your client's company, the competitor's ad is actually showing right at the top of the Yahoo and Google search results.
The third category, which is very much a growing problem, is social media trademark infringement. So it's social media monitoring. Across the hundreds of different social media platforms, a good trademark monitoring software tool will tell you what are the other social media uses of your trademark. So Facebook.com/TraverseLegal, for instance, is a vanity page for our company. There's a vanity Twitter account for Traverse Legal as well. So you want to be able to see when someone else may be using your trademark as a landing page within a social media platform because, quite honestly, if someone else is using your trademark as a "Facebook page", your consumers could actually think that that page belongs to you and could get deceived by the content on that page. If it happens to be a competitior, who is actually running that social media platform, trying to divert your customers, then as an attorney who represents both trademark and cybersquatting interests, I'm going to tell you that you need to do something about that if you want to be able to assert any trademark rights down the line.
The last point I want to make, Matt, is that whenever you send out a trademark infringement threat letter, either for domain name, cybersquatting, key word advertising, trademark infringement or social media trademark infringement, one of the first things that the other lawyer will typically do is see if their client is the only one who's infringing your trademark. If they find that there's 50 other sites, key words, social media tools out there which incorporate your trademark, the first thing they're going to say to you is, "Look at all these other third party uses of your trademark. You can't just go after us." So you want to have a system where you actually go through, you figure out which are the problems and you deal with those problems in a regular, proactive way in order to not only protect your trademark but increase the value of your trademark as an asset for your company.
Matt: And also, Enrico, we're talking about these main points to look for when monitoring. Tell me what kinds of things come up upon monitoring that can be mistaken for problems.
Enrico: So these monitoring tools have all kinds of filtering that they have embedded into them so typically you're going to get a lot of data back. That data then needs to be categorized and filtered because not everything that comes back is going to qualify as trademark infringement. There may be some very legitimate uses. There may be some uses of something that is identical or similar to your trademark but in a different category of good and services so that it really isn't going to cause consumer confusion. You could see instances of your trademark being used by yourself online that'll come back as part of the monitoring.
So, a good trademark attorney who understands the Internet and the online space will be able to use these monitoring tools to be able to generate reports to the client where the attorney is telling the client, "Here are the problems that we think you need to address." So you might take 600 results and cull them down into, say, 40 particular problems that should be dealt with and ten problems that should be dealt with on a priority basis. Your attorney, who understands trademark and Internet issues, will be able to cull through the data and generate a report with recommendations about which of these uses potentially qualify as trademark infringement. Which of the uses are diverting a lot of your customers, which of the uses are, perhaps, capturing your customers' email addresses or other financial information such as credit card information, which could greatly diminish your good will if there's a problem down the line and your customer thinks that you actually are the portal that caused a theft of their credit card information, for instance. Or is now sending you spam because someone collected your email address and all of a sudden is using it as part of these giant spam engines.
So you need to get your attorney involved to do the monitoring, and you can do reports weekly, daily. Usually, quarterly or semi-annually is adequate for virtually any trademark owner to be able to see what is next. What we tell clients, Matt, is to budget, in cooperation with your attorney, budget quarterly an amount which you will use to send threat letters and deal with potential infringement.
You won't be able to ever deal with all the problems that may exist, but you'll be able to deal with certainly the ones that are the most important and the critical item is this. The take-away from this show, Matt, is the fact that you could actually increase your trademark value exponentially by creating a folder of materials which engage in monitoring and enforcement. If any third party comes to buy your company, one of your most important assets is going to be your trademark, and if all you have is a trademark registration certificate, that's not going to be that great. You need a trademark registration certificate plus a whole file devoted to everything that you've done in the Internet space to protect your trademark from online infringement.
Matt: Well, thank you again, as always, Enrico. We appreciate your time.
Enrico: No problem, Matt. Have a great day.
Matt: I'm Matt Plessner and join us next time on Trademark Law Radio.
Announcer: You've been listening to Trademark Law Radio. Whether you are facing a trademark infringement, licensing, monitoring or trademark registration issue, we have a trademark attorney ready to answer your questions.
As a founding partner of Traverse Legal, PLC, he has more than thirty years of experience as an attorney for both established companies and emerging start-ups. His extensive experience includes navigating technology law matters and complex litigation throughout the United States.
This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by attorney Enrico Schaefer, who has more than 20 years of legal experience as a practicing Business, IP, and Technology Law litigation attorney.