Circumstantial Evidence in Domain Disputes

The Nominet UK Dispute Resolution Service has just issued a decision in the Apple Computer Inc. v CyberBritain Group Ltd. Not unexpectedly under the facts presented, Apple Computer Inc. won this domain name cybersquatting arbitration and will receive by court order its domain itunes.co.uk to it.

In this case, Apple registered for UK trademark, and shortly thereafter the respondent registered the itunes.co.uk mark. For a period of time, the itunes.co.uk domain simply redirected users to other commercial sites. In the meantime apple had launched itunes software. The cybersquatting respondent tried to leverage its domain name with a competitor of itunes, Napster. The cybersquatter did however deny that that they had any idea that Apple was going to launch itunes when they registered the domain. The arbitrator  found that, on the balance of probabilities, the respondent registered the domain name in bad faith and detrimental to the rights of Apple. She ordered the domain name be transferred to complainant.

This decision is a good example of how circumstantial evidence is very powerful in the domain name resolution forum. Because there is far less evidence available to arbitrators, they are forced to make findings of fact based on records that are far less involved than in an actual civil litigation. Based on the circumstantial evidence and in the face of denials an arbitrator can find “based on the probabilities that bad faith registration existed.”

📚 Get AI-powered insights from this content:

Author


Enrico Schaefer

As a founding partner of Traverse Legal, PLC, he has more than thirty years of experience as an attorney for both established companies and emerging start-ups. His extensive experience includes navigating technology law matters and complex litigation throughout the United States.

Years of experience: 35+ years
LinkedIn /Justia / YouTube

GET IN Touch

We’re here to field your questions and concerns. If you are a company able to pay a reasonable legal fee each month, please contact us today.

CATEGORIES

#

This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by attorney Enrico Schaefer, who has more than 20 years of legal experience as a practicing Business, IP, and Technology Law litigation attorney.